Data with Bert logo

The Fastest Way To Locate Errors In Your SQL Query

n-120570-2

In about 60 seconds you will never debug error messages in SQL Server Management Studio the same way again.

Coming from a .NET background, I'm used to receiving relatively helpful error messages that point me to the precise location of the error in my code:

NET-Error-Message Pinpoint error finding

SQL Server Management Studio does a decent job too - **except when it doesn't. ** Different versions of SSMS provide error line numbers differently.

Watch this week's video on YouTube

In older versions (<= 2012), SSMS provides error location information relative to the batch starting point of the erroneous query.  This means if you have a window full of T-SQL batch statements, your error message will be relative to the last "GO" in the editor before the syntax error:

Error-message-in-old-SSMS

In SSMS 2014, batch start locations aren't considered:

error-message-ssms-2014

Starting in SSMS 2016, the error messages revert back to counting from the current batch but also indicate the line number where the batch begins:

Error-message-in-newer-ssms

While all of these error messages point me in the right direction, I'm too lazy to try and remember how each version of SSMS refers to the error location.  This becomes particularly problematic when jumping around environments and not being able to use a consistent version of SSMS.

There is one feature that works consistently though that makes navigating to the specific error lines easily.

You can double click on the error message to be taken directly to the line number referenced!

I know this sounds simple, but it's one of those small things I never thought of trying until I saw someone else do it.  Little did I know what I was missing out on - especially in those giant hundreds/thousands of line long scripts.  but now that I know about it it's the only way I locate my query errors.

This functionality also works if you have multiple errors listed in the Messages window.

But what about if your SQL query is all on one giant line (like if it was copied from somewhere or generated dynamically)?  You can use a regular expression to format your query first and then click on the error message to quickly navigate to the correct lines.

Inverted Polygons? How to Troubleshoot SQL Server's Left Hand Rule

inverted-polygon

Last week we looked at how easy it is to import GeoJSON data into SQL Server's geography datatype.

Sometimes your source data won't be perfectly formatted for SQL Server's spatial datatypes though.

Today we'll examine what to do when our geographical polygon is showing us inverted results.

Watch this week's video on YouTube

Colorado Is A Rectangle

If you look at the state of Colorado on a map, you'll notice its border is pretty much a rectangle.

Roughly marking the lat/long coordinates of the state's four corners will give you a polygon comprised of the following points:

colorado-map-lat-longs-1

Or in GeoJSON format (set equal to a SQL variable) you might represent this data like so:

DECLARE @Colorado nvarchar(max) = N'
{
    "type": "FeatureCollection",
    "features": [{
        "type": "Feature",
        "properties": {},
        "geometry": {
            "type": "Polygon",
            "coordinates": [
                [
                    [-109.05005693435669,
                        41.0006946252774
                    ],
                    [-102.05157816410065,
                        41.002362600596015
                    ],
                    [-102.0421314239502,
                        36.993139985820925
                    ],
                    [-109.04520750045776,
                        36.99898824162522
                    ],

                    [-109.05005693435669,
                        41.0006946252774
                    ]
                ]
            ]
        }
    }]
}
'

Note: four points + one extra point that is a repeat of our first point - this last repeated point let's us know that we have a closed polygon since it ends at the same point where it began.

Viewing Our Colorado Polygon

Converting this array of points to the SQL Server geography datatype is pretty straight forward:

SELECT
    geography::STPolyFromText(
        'POLYGON ((' + STRING_AGG(CAST(Long + ' ' + Lat as varchar(max)), ',') + '))'
        ,4326) AS StateBoundary
FROM
    (
    SELECT 
        Long,
        Lat
    FROM
        OPENJSON(@Colorado, '$.features[0].geometry.coordinates[0]')
        WITH
            (
                Long varchar(100) '$[0]',
                Lat varchar(100) '$[1]'
            )
)d

We can then take a look at SQL Server Management Studio's Spatial Results tab and see our polygon of Colorado drawn on a map.  You might notice something looks a little funny with this picture though:

spatial-results-inverted-rectangle

WHY IS MY POLYGON AREA INVERTED?!!??!

Discerning eyes might notice that SQL Server didn't shade in the area inside of the polygon - it instead shaded in everything in the world EXCEPT for the interior of our polygon.

If this is the first time you've encountered this behavior then you're probably confused by this behavior - I know I was.

The Left-Hand/Right-Hand Rules

There is a logical explanation though for why SQL Server is seemingly shading in the wrong part of our polygon.

SQL Server's geography datatype follows the "left-hand rule" when determining which side of the polygon should be shaded.  On the contrary, the GeoJSON specification specifies objects should be formed following the "right-hand rule."

The left hand rule works like this: imagine you are walking the path of polygon - whatever is to the left of the line you are walking is what is considered the "interior" of that polygon.

So if we draw arrows that point in the direction that the coordinates are listed in our GeoJSON, you'll notice we are making our polygon in a clockwise direction:

arrows-2

If you imagine yourself walking along this line in the direction specified, you'll quickly see why SQL Server shades the "outside" of the polygon: following the left-hand rule, everything except for the state of Colorado is considered the interior of our polygon shape.

Reversing Polygon Direction

So the problem here is that our polygon data was encoded in a different direction than the SQL Server geography datatype expects.

One way to fix this is to correct our source data by reordering the points so that the polygon is drawn in a counter-clockwise direction:

-- Note: The middle three sets of points have been included in reverse order while the first/last point have stayed the same
DECLARE @ColoradoReversed nvarchar(max) = N'
{
    "type": "FeatureCollection",
    "features": [{
        "type": "Feature",
        "properties": {},
        "geometry": {
            "type": "Polygon",
            "coordinates": [
                [
                    [-109.05005693435669,
                        41.0006946252774
                    ],
                    [-109.04520750045776,
                        36.99898824162522
                    ],
                    [-102.0421314239502,
                        36.993139985820925
                    ],

                    [-102.05157816410065,
                        41.002362600596015
                    ],

                    [-109.05005693435669,
                        41.0006946252774
                    ]
                ]
            ]
        }
    }]
}
'

This is pretty easy to do with a polygon that only has five points, but this would be a huge pain for a polygon with hundreds or thousands of points.

So how do we solve this in a more efficient manner?

Easy, use SQL Server's ReorientObject() function.

SELECT
    geography::STPolyFromText(
        'POLYGON ((' + STRING_AGG(CAST(Long + ' ' + Lat as varchar(max)), ',') + '))'
        ,4326).ReorientObject() AS StateBoundary
FROM
    (
    SELECT 
        Long,
        Lat
    FROM
        OPENJSON(@Colorado, '$.features[0].geometry.coordinates[0]')
        WITH
            (
                Long varchar(100) '$[0]',
                Lat varchar(100) '$[1]'
            )
)d

ReorientObject() does what we did manually above - it manipulates the order of our polygon's points so that it changes the direction in which the polygon is drawn.

Note: SQL uses a different order when reversing the points using ReorientObject() than the way we reversed them above.  The end result ends up being the same however.

Regardless of which method you choose to use, the results are the same: our polygon of Colorado is now drawn in the correct direction and the Spatial Results tab visually confirms this for us:

spatial-correct-results

Importing GeoJSON Earthquake Data Into SQL Server

IMG_0397 A significant portion of Yellowstone National Park sits on top of a supervolcano.  Although it's not likely to erupt any time soon, the park is constantly monitored for geological events like earthquakes.

This week I want to take a look at how you can import this earthquake data, encoded in GeoJSON format, into SQL Server in order to be able to analyze it using SQL Server's spatial functions.

Watch this week's video on YouTube

GeoJSON

The source for the data we'll be using is the 30-day earthquake feed from the USGS.  This data is encoded in the GeoJSON format, a specification that makes it easy to share spatial data via JSON.  To get an idea of how it looks, here's an extract:

{
    "type": "FeatureCollection",
    "metadata": {
        "generated": 1515603955000,
        "url": "https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/feed/v1.0/summary/1.0_month.geojson",
        "title": "USGS Magnitude 1.0+ Earthquakes, Past Month",
        ...
    },
    "features": [{
            "type": "Feature",
            "properties": {
                "mag": 1.25,
                "place": "7km NW of The Geysers, CA",
                "time": 1515603166510,
                ...
            },
            "geometry": {
                "type": "Point",
                "coordinates": [-122.8221664, 38.8175011, 2.02]
            },
            "id": "nc72952110"
        },
        ...
        ],
    "bbox": [-179.921, -62.519, -3.35, 179.9551, 85.3951, 608.58]
}

The key thing we'll be examining in this data is the "features" array: it contains one feature object for each earthquake that's been recorded in the past 30 days.  You can see the "geometry" child object contains lat/long coordinates that we'll be importing into SQL Server.

If you want the same 30-day GeoJSON extract we'll be using in all of the following demo code, you can download it here.

Importing GeoJSON into SQL Server

There's no out of the box way to import GeoJSON data into SQL Server.

However, using SQL Server's JSON functions we can build our own solution pretty easily.

First, let's create a table where we can store all of earthquake data:

CREATE TABLE dbo.EarthquakeData
(
    Id int IDENTITY PRIMARY KEY,
    EventDate DATETIME2,
    Magnitude FLOAT,
    Place VARCHAR(300),
    Coordinates GEOGRAPHY,
    Long varchar(100),
    Lat varchar(100)
)

CREATE SPATIAL INDEX IX_Coordinates ON dbo.EarthquakeData (Coordinates)

Then, let's use the OPENJSON() function to parse our JSON and insert it into our table:

DECLARE @GeoJSON nvarchar(max) = N'{...}' -- Put the GeoJSON here

INSERT INTO dbo.EarthquakeData (EventDate,Magnitude,Place,Coordinates,Long,Lat)
SELECT 
    -- Convert unix epoch time to datetime
    -- We also know the source is in UTC, so we specify that using AT TIME ZONE for easier conversions down the road
    DATEADD(second,cast(UnixMillisecondsSinceEpoch/1000 as int),'1970-01-01 00:00:00') AT TIME ZONE 'UTC' AS EventDate,
    Magnitude,
    Place,
    -- Build our geography datatype
    geography::STPointFromText('POINT ('+Long + ' ' + Lat + ')', 4326) AS Geography,
    Long,
    Lat
FROM 
    OPENJSON(@GeoJSON, '$.features')
        WITH (
            UnixMillisecondsSinceEpoch bigint '$.properties.time',
            Magnitude float '$.properties.mag',
            Place varchar(300) '$.properties.place',
            Long varchar(100) '$.geometry.coordinates[0]',
            Lat varchar(100) '$.geometry.coordinates[1]'
        )

We use OPENJSON() to parse our JSON hierarchy and then concatenate together the lat and long values into our well known text format to be able to use it with SQL Server's spatial function STPointFromText:

SELECT geography::STPointFromText('POINT ('+Long + ' ' + Lat + ')', 4326) AS Geography

What results is our earthquake data all nicely parsed out into our dbo.EarthquakeData table:

Earthquake-data-parsed

What about Yellowstone?

The above data includes earthquakes from around world.  Since we only want to examine earthquakes in Yellowstone, we'll need to filter the data out.

There's a handy Place column in the data that we could probably add a LIKE '%yellowstone%' filter to - but this is a post about spatial data in SQL, we can do better!

The Wyoming State Geological Survey website has Shapefiles for the boundary of Yellowstone National Park.  Since we are practicing our GeoJSON import skills, I converted the Shapefiles to GeoJSON using an online converter and the resulting data looks like this:

{
    "type": "FeatureCollection",
    "bbox": [-111.15354785438899, 44.13238494057162, -109.816111731858, 45.102865336505396],
    "features": [{
        "type": "Feature",
        "geometry": {
            "type": "Polygon",
            "coordinates": [
                [
                    [-111.0970801722779, 44.487322588834374],
                    [-111.09707931336956, 44.48929779632266],
                    [-111.09707877845554, 44.49109904485493],
                    [-111.09707888353985, 44.49472122457225],.
                    ...
                ]
            ]
        },
        ...
    }]
}

You can download the full park boundary GeoJSON file here.

Just like before, we'll use SQL Server's OPENJSON() function to parse our GeoJSON data into a well-known text POLYGON.

First we create our table:

DROP TABLE IF EXISTS dbo.ParkBoundaries
CREATE TABLE dbo.ParkBoundaries
(
    Id int IDENTITY PRIMARY KEY,
    ParkName varchar(100),
    ParkBoundary GEOGRAPHY
)
CREATE SPATIAL INDEX IX_Boundary ON dbo.ParkBoundaries (ParkBoundary)

And then populate it, this time using the STPolyFromText spatial function:

INSERT INTO dbo.ParkBoundaries (ParkName, ParkBoundary)
SELECT
    'Yellowstone National Park' AS ParkName,
    geography::STPolyFromText('POLYGON ((' + STRING_AGG(CAST(Long + ' ' + Lat as varchar(max)), ',') + '))',4326).ReorientObject() AS ParkBoundary
FROM
    (
    SELECT 
        Long,
        Lat
    FROM
        OPENJSON(@Yellowstone, '$.features[0].geometry.coordinates[0]')
        WITH
            (
                Long varchar(100) '$[0]',
                Lat varchar(100) '$[1]'
            )
)d

Filtering our data

Now we have two tables: dbo.EarthquakeData and dbo.ParkBoundaries.  What we want to do is select only the Earthquake data points that fall within the boundaries of Yellowstone National Park.

This is easy to do using the STIntersects spatial function, which returns a "1" for any rows where one geography instance (our lat/long earthquake coordinate) intersects another geography instance (our park boundary):

SELECT 
    d.Id,
    d.Magnitude,
    d.EventDate,
    d.Place,
    b.ParkName
FROM 
    dbo.EarthQuakeData d
    CROSS JOIN dbo.ParkBoundaries b
WHERE
    Coordinates.STIntersects(ParkBoundary) =1
    AND b.ParkName = 'Yellowstone National Park'
ORDER BY
    Magnitude DESC

The rest is up to you

So all it takes to import GeoJSON data into SQL Server is knowing how to use SQL Server's JSON functions.

Once geographical data is imported into geography data types, SQL Server's spatial functions offer lots of flexibility for how to efficiently slice and dice the data.

I Have A SQL Login - Why Can't I Connect?

tsqltuesdaylogo

This post is a response to this month's T-SQL Tuesday prompt created by Arun SirpalAdam Machanic created T-SQL Tuesday as a way for SQL users to share ideas about interesting topics. This month's topic is "Your Technical Challenges Conquered".


DBA Skills 101: SQL Logins

While writing last week's post about efficiently scripting database objects, I decided to make progress towards my 2018 learning goals by figuring out what database permissions were needed for running SQL Server Management Studio's "Generate Scripts" tool.

I thought it would be best to start with a clean slate so I created a new SQL login and database user so that I could definitively figure out which permissions are needed.

Normally I use Windows Authentication for my logins, but this time I thought "since I'm getting crazy learning new things, let me try creating a SQL Login instead."

After I created my login, I decided to test connecting to my server before digging into the permissions.  Result?

Watch this week's video on YouTube

I can't connect!

That's right, I tried to connect and I got this very detailed error message :

Login failed for user Microsoft SQL Server Error: 18456

"Great," I thought.  "I should just switch to a Windows Authentication login, those always work for me."

"BUT NO, THEN I WON'T LEARN ANYTHING!"

On to troubleshooting

First things first, I tried retyping my login and password (I know typing in the password of "password" is really tricky but I've made mistakes doing much simpler things).

No luck.  Maybe when I created the login I fat-fingered the password?

I recreated the login, making sure I precisely typed the password.  Try to connect again...nope.

Ok, ok.  I'm missing something obvious.  I have this error message though - maybe the internet will know!

I find the exact error message in a blog post by Aaron Bertrand - he's a credible guy, I bet I'll find the solution there!

Nope.

(Side note: the answer is there, just buried in the comments.  In my eager "this will be an easy solution" I didn't bother scrolling down that far).

Ok... how about books online?  Even though I created the login through the SSMS GUI, I know the T-SQL command to do the same is CREATE LOGIN.  Maybe I'll find the solution in the documentation?

No luck.

(Side note again: in hindsight you can get to the solution from the above link, but it's buried two further links deep.  While troubleshooting I was in the mindset of "ain't nobody got time for that" - I wanted a solution given to me immediately without having to do any further research!)

I kept searching online, reading through Stack Overflow answers, not finding what I needed.

(Side note (last one, I promise): anyone else having a harder time searching for relevant Stack Overflow answers?  It feels like more and more I find questions/answers that are for older versions and no longer relevant)

At this point I was really frustrated.  "CREATING A LOGIN SHOULD BE LIKE THE FIRST THING A DBA LEARNS!! WHY IS THIS SO HARD?!?!?!?!?!?!"

At that point I was tired and disappointed that I had spent more time trying to solve this login problem rather than actually figuring out the permissions that I wanted to include in my blog post.

Sleep

I decided to take a break for the night and revisit the problem the next morning.

As expected, I searched the internet for the answer again and somehow my keyword selection hit the jackpot - I found the Stack Overflow answer telling me I needed to set the server to mixed authentication mode:

mixed-authentication-mode

Wow, that was easy.

Takeaway

This wasn't a complex problem.  At least, it shouldn't have been a complex problem.

All in all I spent probably 30 minutes trying to figure it out - not the longest amount of time I've sunk into a problem that ended up having a really simple solution.

However, this stuff happens.  It's amazing what a fresh (rested) set of eyes can do for solving a problem.

Lesson learned: next time I'm getting frustrated by a problem that I think should be easy to solve, I need to step away from the computer and come back once I have a clearer mindset :).

One Last Technical Challenge (BONUS)

I figured I'd add one more technical challenge to this post: submit a pull request to the sql-docs GitHub.

My rationale was that I couldn't be the only person to have ever been stumped by authentication modes.  Maybe I could be helpful to the next person who visits the CREATE LOGIN books online page and give them a hint as to why they can't connect.

Contributing to open source isn't something I've done through Github before, but luckily I had Steve Jones's excellent write up to guide me.

There were no real challenges here since I was just making a simple edit, and low and behold a few days later my PR got merged and is now live in BOL - cool!

A Better Way To Script Database Objects

Happy New Year! My New Year's resolution for 2018 is to help you become a better SQL developer.

I want to start off with that today by showing you a much better way to generate database object change scripts.

Watch this week's video on YouTube

If you are like I used to be for YEARS, anytime you want to copy a table, index, etc... you probably right click on that object in SQL Server Management Studio and click "Script as" > "CREATE To":

old-create-to An inefficient way of generating change scripts

This is a pretty easy way to quickly script database objects, however it's incomplete.

For starters, I'm forced to generate the scripts for tables one at a time.  Not fun.

Additionally, if I want to script associated objects for that table, like indexes, I have to go to each index and then right-click and select "Script Index as".  Ugh.

There Is A Better Way

Instead of using "Script Table as", you can right click on your database and choose "Tasks" > "Generate Scripts...":

generate-scripts

This option brings up a GUI that will allow you to script multiple objects at the same time:

multiple-objects-at-once Look ma, multiple objects at once!

Additionally if you click the "Advanced" button in the final page of the dialog, you will receive many more options for how your objects will get scripted, including the ability to script out the indexes!

script-indexes Ooooooo, ahhhh - everything scripted in one fell swoop!

Using the Generate Scripts Task it's easy to generate table, index, stored procedure, etc... change scripts all in one step - nice!

NOTE: If your SQL User receives an error when trying to generate the scripts, make sure they have the following access:

USE [MyDatabase]
GO

GRANT VIEW DEFINITION TO [MyUser]
GO

GRANT SELECT ON sys.sql_expression_dependencies TO [MyUser]
GO

sql_expression_dependceis